Doc’s Axe
I have a book that gathers dust in the highest reaches of my library. It shares a shelf with Mothercraft and The Idiot’s Guide to Genealogy. And What They Don’t Teach You in Harvard Business School. The title of this book is Alcoholics Anonymous. I climbed up and brought it down today.
I want to find out the reason that some people, when they are drinking, become completely different people. I’ve seen some, who don’t normally talk much, begin to talk a lot more. And some who are shy become sociable. I’ve heard reports of ordinarily generous folks inviting strangers home to the family dinner. But they don’t change fundamentally. They are more like the humorous person who becomes downright hilarious. Their nature is still essentially the same. Each has a consistent character, whether he has had a beer or three, or a half dozen slugs of whiskey. Or not.
I want to know how it is that a kind and decent sober person can transmute into a raging murderous maniacal drunk? And how do the people he hurts or threatens find the strength to forgive him?
Characters in novels are sometimes one-dimensional; the best ones may have depth and breadth. The good people, in a pretty good read, are almost always good. Heroes in books have few faults, and even those are generally minor. Fictional villains are usually perfectly evil. In life, though, we have all the dimensions. No human being is perfect at anything, even wickedness. Some good thought or deed rears its head on occasion. And in reality, even the most thoroughly virtuous will commit a sin or two now and then. But that’s as it should be. What’s virtue if there’s no struggle in it? It’s as empty as courage without fear.
Alcoholics Anonymous, it turns out, is a book about faith and forgiveness. According to its copyright page, it was first published in 1939. A good year for it. The World War and Prohibition seemed to have joined forces to give cocktails a dangerous and sophisticated allure. Whatever caused it, a whole lot of drinking went on in the middle part of the last century. Prohibition removed the protection of legal standards, so that any old booze would do. Most of it was stronger that it had been before, because hoodlums didn’t want to transport milder liquors, heavy with diluting agents. And a good bit of it was homemade and downright poisonous. The result was more addiction to alcohol and more instances of drunken craziness. Prohibition by another name continued on down into the 1960s in our county and produced our share of bootleggers and home distilled spirits of varying potency and questionable potability.
But what about my two questions? Logic could get me through the first one. Chemistry and psychology and biology—they could give me the solution to that first part of the conundrum, if I were smart enough. And so then we’d could puzzle out what forces of nature and spirit and circumstance compelled to Doc come after Eli on Christmas morning of 1945, with an axe.
We wouldn’t even need those sciences to know why Kathleen threw herself between them and came away bloodied and beaten for her trouble. Her motives were simple and instant. She would not let Doc hurt Eli. But I’d have to refer the faith part of the problem to understand how either Kathleen or Eli could ever forgive Doc for his alcohol-induced lapse out of Doc-ness or to understand how they learned to trust him again. But he was human and they were human, and with faith enough and love enough, they just did.
Aunt Nancy remembers that Christmas morning, the first Christmas after Ross was killed by the Japanese on one of those hellish islands in the Pacific. It had been a dreadful, struggling slog through thick grief for her and for every single person she loved. Christmas might have provided a small bright spot, a tiny star of hope on the horizon. But it wasn’t to be.
Nancy was up early. She saw Kathleen come in the door, sobbing, her pink robe and nightgown splattered with blood. That sight itself was terrifying for an eleven-year-old girl, but the story Kathleen told between sobs was worse. Doc had been drinking for days. She’d wanted him to sober up for Christmas when all the family would be together. He wouldn’t listen to reason, and he couldn’t see her family in the shape he was in. And so she’d asked Eli to come and help her.
The only thing she knew to do was cut off Doc’s supply, and so she and Eli set out to find his stash of alcohol and get rid of it. They’d started the day before, on Christmas Eve, in the places he’d be likely to search out as a last ditch effort to get some alcohol into his body. They searched the bathroom and bedrooms and poured out cologne, cough syrup, rubbing alcohol and hair tonic, anything with alcohol as an ingredient. They’d ransacked the kitchen, dining room, and the utility closet and thrown out all kinds of unlikely suspects, but never found where his whiskey was.
So Eli decided to watch where Doc couldn’t see him. On his way home Christmas Eve just after sundown, he’d waited in the woods back of the house. He saw Doc come out and go to the shed. Eli crept up and got a good look where the stash was hidden and decided to avoid an argument and come back first thing in the morning, before Doc would be awake.
Next morning just after dawn, Kathleen was up drinking coffee and making sweet potato pie to take to Big Mama’s house for the Christmas dinner. She saw from the kitchen window Eli going into the shed and knew he’d found where Doc’s liquor was hidden. She took a deep breath and felt tremendous relief. Eli would take care of it. Doc would have to sober up now.
A half-minute later Doc stumbled through the kitchen, headed for his shed. Kathleen was stunned for a moment, frozen and speechless with apprehension. The jig might be up. Then she thought “Oh, no you don’t” and got her legs to moving. She ran across the yard after Doc, hoping to delay him long enough to let Eli get done with what he’d come to do. But Doc got to the shed seconds before she did. During those long seconds, he saw that Eli had poured out every drop of whiskey he had.
Anger swept over Doc like none he’d ever felt before. He was blind with fury. It was as if Eli became everyone and everything that had ever controlled Doc’s life from the moment of his birth. He was the symbol for all Doc’s shortcomings, for all he had done, but mostly for all he had failed to do: for his guilt over not going with the boys who went to war, because he wasn’t man enough overrule his parents who’d said “people of our class don’t go to fight;” for watching Ross, a boy of nineteen, go and die; and for being powerless to assuage in some small degree Kathleen’s grief, her family’s grief and his own. His hand found the handle of the axe leaning against the door jamb. In one motion the axe was over Doc’s head and Kathleen had him by his arm. He jerked his elbow back to pull free, and she felt a blow across her face. Blood gushed and Doc dropped the axe in horror. For a second and for the first time in days he was shocked sober, but then he fell, moaning, to ground. Eli pulled Kathleen out of the shed and they ran. They ran all the way home to Eunice.
There were two entire families who had to forgive Doc: Kathleen’s and Eli’s. In the case of Eli’s family, they relied on the rote-learned words of their Christian belief. Antique King James English, spoken in their Southern American dialect. “Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us.” They prayed it and they lived it everyday. They’d forgiven so many trespasses, big and small, down through the years and their forebears had forgiven more. Doc’s trespass was only another. Eli believed Doc was a good man in the grasp of the devil and his demon rum. He’d seen many a man ruin himself on rotgut. He’d seen ‘em go crazy on bad liquor, high-stepping and trembling with the jake leg, and then dying not long after. Eli prayed daily that God might loose the devil’s grasp on the Doctor.
Eunice was much angrier at first and more frightened than Eli, but she calmed down and went to Kathleen’s aid. Eunice vowed to pray for Kathleen. Even with a houseful of sympathy and a cold cloth on her bloody nose, Kathleen could not stop sobbing. Eunice and Eli decided he’d best take her on home to her mama and daddy.
Kathleen’s daddy was perhaps the sweetest man who ever lived. He loved all children, even the tiny newborns that most men are slightly afraid of. He was so kind-hearted that he hated to spank his own children. Big Mama used to get so mad because he’d laugh and say to her “Why do I need to spank them, when you do it so well?” or “I just leave the spanking to Dolly, because she seems to get so much pleasure out of it.”
He was the first love of Kathleen’s life, though her step-father. Big Daddy was so unlike, she’d been told, that father she didn’t remember. He had taken her into his heart before she was done toddling, right along with her mother. And she was just as important to him. He loved them both. He was an even-tempered man who loved two strong-willed spitfires. So from her earliest memories, Kathleen grew up adored and petted and looked after by Big Daddy. She’s tease her younger sisters by saying “See? I’m Daddy’s favorite.” And he never denied it. He was, as the Psalm says, “slow to anger, rich in kindness.” Along with his easy-going nature, Big Daddy had a quiet, determined, bone-deep strength that lay in wait for trouble.
When Big Daddy saw Kathleen, sobbing and bloody, the anger came. He did not shout. He spoke deliberately and quietly. He was not a big man. He was not a man who wasted words. And he never cussed. I suspect he thought the appropriate moment for cussing had come when he said, “I’ll kick that son of bitch’s ass till his nose bleeds.” Within a few moments, Big Daddy was in Doc’s house, confronting him with his crime. Their conversation was short, but pithy with meaning. Big Daddy made his point directly and with the kind of imperative fortitude needed to penetrate Doc’s fog of shame and alcohol.
“Doc, you like your life?”
Doc looked at the floor, and nodded. “Yes. I do.”
“Well, if you ever lay a hand on Kathleen again, you will lose it.”
Doc nodded again.
Kathleen and her family forgave Doc, after a lot of praying and a length of time. And he never raised a hand in anger to anyone again, until the night he died.
The Right Southern Corner is a series by Sara Rast
Copyright: 2009 Sara Love Rast. All rights reserved.



