A Suspect
It was only a few days after the murders, and Byrd thought of somebody who might have done it.
After the double funeral on Monday, he’d tossed and turned at lot — truth be told, he hadn’t slept much all week. Byrd had stood right up there in the Methodist Church the day of that double funeral. Stood right down there in front next to the altar and pledged to himself, as he hoisted his part of Doc’s casket on to his shoulder, that he wouldn’t rest till they put somebody in jail for these killin’s. And he didn’t rest. He could barely close his eyes. But on Thursday morning he got right up and went straight on to the Sheriff’s house in Ashville, just like any good citizen would’ve done. He figured he had the answer.
He was awake most of those nights pondering on these killin’s and all the evidence that was being collected. He’d felt sure to start with, because of the fire, there wouldn’t be much evidence to collect. But, apparently, there had been quite a lot.
That Wednesday night after the Coroner’s jury come back with a verdict, Byrd begun to study on the question pretty serious. Hank Spain, the coroner, had done right well with that jury on Saturday. Near ’bout had ‘em come back that day with a verdict of accidental death. That would’ve been the best thing. That was what ever-body said it was, even the city newspaper. But a few of ‘em in there on that jury refused to cooperate. Hank said it was that Fate Wilkinson and Brother Herman that couldn’t be reasoned with. Said they insisted on waitin’ till the autopsy report was in. Dang elders of the Methodist Church.
Well, they adjourned on Saturday evenin’ and come back Tuesday morning to convene again. So Byrd went up there and parked his car out by the courthouse and waited a while, till he saw Rufus Samples drivin’ one of Hank’s taxis. Rufus dropped Lother Green off at the corner drugstore. Since he’d gotten so old, Lother always took the taxi to the drugstore on Tuesday afternoons about one o’clock. That was when the old men at Wisdom Corner got started up with their afternoon session of opinionatin’. Byrd tried to sit in with ‘em once in a while, just often enough the keep his finger on the pulse of the town’s opinion. Or more like to keep his finger in the pie. That day though, Byrd had something else on his mind. He waved Rufus over to send him on a little errand.
Rufus was accustomed to runnin’ errands around town. He’d go for medicine when somebody’s child was sick. Been sent to pick up a many a grocery order and went on in through the kitchen door and put the stuff up in the cabinets, if he knew where it belonged. Been sent for home-made whiskey or bonded, depending on the customers’ tastes, when a body wasn’t able to git out and git their own for one reason or another. Anything that required an automobile where none was to be had, Rufus did it for a small fee. Lot of folks did without automobiles around town back then.
Byrd’s errand wasn’t going to take him all that far. All he wanted was for Rufus to go in there in the room where that coroner’s jury was meeting and get Hank to come on out and visit with him a while in his car. So Byrd scribbled out something on a little piece of note paper and folded it up real little, and Rufus carried it in there and slipped it to Hank in the jury room and left. And tucked the extra dollar in his pocket. Like fallin’ off a log.
In a little bit, here come Hank and gets in Byrd’s car. They disappear out back of the Wo-Co-Pep, and Rufus didn’t know what become of ‘em after that. He went on back to the taxi stand to wait for another call.
In the jury room, Hank Spain had told that he was going out to talk to Rufus. Since he was the coroner and the foreman of the jury, he put himself in charge. He said he’d go ask Rufus about that trip folks were saying he made out to the McIntosh house the night of the fire. Mrs. Buttram had said in town that it was Hank himself that went out there, but Hank had already denied that. So he told ‘em he’d go ask Rufus.
The jury and the witnesses waited for the coroner to come back before anything else was discussed. It seemed like the right thing at the time. And that state toxicologist, Rivers, that done the autopsy, he was there with his report waiting to tell about it. Brother Herman said he looked at his watch when the coroner stepped out of the room, and that it was about sixteen minutes after one. And after a while Mr. Latimer got to thinking about a Co-cola, it being so hot in there. And he spoke right up and said he wanted one and could he bring one back for anybody else. Mr. Wilkinson said he believed he would have one. So Mr. Latimer walked out to the service station to get a couple out of the cooler.
As he come out holding the Co-cola bottles in one hand, Mr. Latimer held the door open for Gladys Albright with the other and happened to glance back towards the alley. There was Byrd Richardson’s Lincoln, and the foreman of the jury, the coroner, and the owner of the taxi company sitting back there in the alley in the Lincoln with Byrd. And that just added up to two people total. Mr. Latimer found something odd in that, so he mentioned it under his breath to Brother Herman soon as he could get back in the room. Didn’t take five minutes before the whole jury knew where Spain was and who he was talking to. Of course, they managed to get it all around the room without lettin’ on to the witness, Dr. Rivers. But, in about twelve hours, everybody else in town knew it. And Hank Spain was defeated in the next election.
Brother said it was twenty-seven minutes altogether before Hank Spain come back to the jury room. And that’s when he told, with the straightest face you ever saw. that he had established without a doubt that none of his drivers made a trip to the McIntosh house the night the couple died. The jury just nodded at him and knew what they knew.
Then, finally, they let that doctor testify about his autopsy. He just started off and kept on till he was done talking and told it all in one piece. What he told made the folks that had to hear it cringe and shudder quite a lot. Brother Herman turned green and got queasy. Two three times we thought he’d have to go out.
Seven knife wounds in the doctor’s heart and two in his left lung. His lower body and limbs so burned away as to make “determination of sex” impossible. The room full of men gasped all at once at the thought of that.
“The other body,” the jury knew, was Kathleen, although there was so little of her left, the doctor said, there was no way to tell for sure who it was. He said there was whole lot less of her left than there was of Doc. “Smaller in stature,” the man said, “her body was more nearly consumed by fire.” There wasn’t much left beyond just the internal parts of her torso, and not much of that. Almost all her the bones were gone, but just a bit of skull left. Her chest was almost all burned away. There just was enough of Kathleen’s heart left to tell there was an “intra-pericardial hemorrhage.” Meaning she was stabbed too. How many times she was stabbed or whether it was actually what killed her, it was impossible for Dr. Rivers to say.
It occurred to somebody that the fire had been hotter that burned the woman. So he asked was there more gasoline poured on her than him. And the doctor said that he couldn’t say for sure what the fuel was, as all of it, of course, had burned away, but in his judgment there was more of it used on the smaller body. And then it occurred to two or three people that maybe it was Kathleen the killer was really mad at.
There was the question of carbon-monoxide poisoning. On this the state toxicologist was clear. “They could’ve died of it, but it was the stab wounds that made them collapse into unconsciousness from shock before the fire was underway. They would’ve died from the stabbing, if there had been no fire at all. So the question’s moot.”
Mr. Spain sat and listened to all of this testimony on the autopsy and said right out before anybody else could talk, said, “It sounds like a clear case of murder/suicide to me,” and he asked if Dr. Rivers didn’t think it was too.
Dr. Rivers looked at him for a long minute and answered “No.” Said, “It couldn’t have been murder/suicide. Because in all my professional career, I’ve never heard of anybody stabbing their spouse to death and then stabbing himself to death and then pouring gasoline over both of them and lighting a match. If the point had been only murder/suicide, the addition of the gasoline and the match would have been superfluous.”
Murder/suicide had sounded about right to Byrd when he and Hank had discussed it. But when the jury come back they’d decided it was “murder by party or parties unknown.”
Byrd was near ’bout runnin’ on empty by Wednesday night. He hadn’t slept much at all since the latter part of the week before. Naturally, he’d been worrying about these murders. There’d been law all over the place. Autopsies and fire marshalls. State investigators asking questions.
When he got to Ashville Thursday morning, he told the Sheriff Dodge, “I don’t know why in hell I never thought about this un before now. Don’t know what took me so long.”
Sheriff Dodge looked squint-eyed at Byrd and said, “Say, you don’t?”
“Naw.This is the very one. Got to be. Got the motive. Got plenty of opportunity.”
Sheriff said, “Who you reckon did it then?”
Byrd was real pleased with himself. “Well, it just makes sense when you think about it. It had to be that hired man of Doc’s, lives out there behind ‘em. Eli Neeley.”
“What kind of motive’s he got. What did he have against Doc and nem?”
“Why, don’t you remember a couple years ago on Christmas? Doc come after him with an axe.”
So a week after the murders, the sheriff contacted the State Police and they come and got Eli and took him off to the jail. Searched all in his house for bloody clothes and the knife and such like. Turned ever-thang up and looked under it, Eunice just a-fussin’ at ‘em the whole time. Took his only pair of good shoes and sent ‘em off to be examined for evidence. Eli missed a week’s work at the cotton mill and figured it’d cost him his job too, being accused of something he didn’t do. Then he thought he’d be real lucky to get out of this thing alive.
Eli worried the whole time the law had kept him penned up in that jail. Not about them lynchin’ him or such as that, although that did cross his mind. What he worried about was that Miss Kathleen’s folks would think he did it. The law wanted it to be him. He had a tight alibi, but he didn’t know if they’d see fit to check it out or not. Been to Birmin’ham that night to the All Night Sing. A hundred different people saw him. After a time, a few days, the law give up. Eli reckoned they’d talked to some of those people. They couldn’t find nothin’ on him. But he knew they sho’ wanted to. They had to come and let him out, and he could see how bad they hated it. The state kept his shoes that cost him a days wages new. Never sent ‘em back. But the mill kept him on at his job and that was a blessin’.
And the next day, after Eli got let out, he gathered up his courage and went to see Miss Kathleen’s folks. He knew Kathleen’s Daddy and Miss Dolly, they might wanna cuss ‘im. They might hate ‘im. Might believe them white folks that said he was the one that done it. But he had to see ‘um anyhow. He wanted to look Miss Kathleen’s folks in the eye so they could see the truth in him. He wanted them to know he never could have done such a thing as that. He wouldn’t never hurt the doctor nor Miss Kathleen. He was ready to take up the Scriptures and swear an oath on it.
And so Eli knocked on their door ready to be cussed. And he waited with a sort of wince on his face and in his heart too. But, when Miss Dolly opened the door, she didn’t cuss him. She said ” Oh, Eli. Come on in. It’s about time them witless scoundrels finally let you out.” Praise be to the Lord. Miss Kathleen’s folks didn’t hate him. Her Daddy said, “Eli, we knew you never did it. We knew you didn’t have it in you to be killin’ folks.” They all stood there in Miss Dolly’s living room and wept together and shared the burden of their grief with each other. Eli told ‘em Eunice was a-praying for ‘em all the time. And Eli prayed to Jesus right then and called out to Him that He’d lift them folks up. But Eli’s load, it was lighter already, ’cause Miss Kathleen’s folks believed him. They knowed it wasn’t Eli that done them evil killin’s.
The Right Southern Corner is a series by Sara Rast
Copyright: 2009 Sara Love Rast. All rights reserved.

